Silver Supply, Demand, Equities, and Market Hubs
September 10, 2025
silver

As a person who follows commodity markets, I've long been captivated by silver's unique position as both an industrial powerhouse and a monetary asset. In September 2025, silver's landscape has intensified, with prices surging to $41.06 per ounce on September 10—up 0.45% daily, 9.15% monthly, and a staggering 43.22% year-to-date from $28.92 at the start of the year. This rally, hitting 14-year highs above $41.38 on September 8, reflects escalating supply deficits, record industrial consumption, and a widening chasm between paper trading and physical availability. Trading hubs like COMEX play a pivotal role, yet their paper-heavy nature often masks physical realities. This updated analysis delves into these dynamics, incorporating fresh September data on prices and forecasts, alongside silver equities' leveraged performance, to uncover opportunities in this tightening market.

Silver Supply: Persistent Constraints Amid Record Deficits
Global silver supply remains stubbornly inelastic, with mine production edging up just 0.9% to 819.7 million ounces (Moz) in 2024, per the Silver Institute’s World Silver Survey 2025. Mexico, Peru, and China dominate output at over 50%, but challenges abound: declining ore grades have cut efficiency by up to 20% in mature deposits, while environmental regulations in South America delay projects by 5-10 years on average. Mexico's Peñasquito mine, producing 10.3 Moz in 2024, exemplifies this—labor strikes and water shortages slashed output by 15% mid-year. Recycling added a record 193.9 Moz in 2024, up 6% from 2023, driven by industrial scrap like ethylene oxide catalysts yielding 50 Moz alone.Yet, total supply hit only 1.01 Boz, creating a 148.9 Moz deficit—the fourth straight year, with cumulative shortfalls from 2021-2024 totaling 678 Moz, equivalent to 10 months of mine output. For 2025, supply is forecast to rise 3% to 1.05 Boz, but the deficit narrows just 21% to 117.6 Moz as demand holds firm—now the fifth consecutive year of shortfall, per the Silver Institute's January update. Geopolitical tensions, including U.S. tariffs on Mexican imports (up to 25%), threaten another 5-10% supply hit, exacerbating the crunch. In my view, these inelastic supplies—unchanged since 2014—signal a structural vulnerability, with above-ground stocks at historic lows of 155 Moz in LBMA vaults, a 140-year nadir. September's price surge to $41 underscores this tightness, as miners struggle to ramp up amid rising costs now 10-15% higher year-over-year.

 

Silver Demand: Industrial Surge Fuels Deficits

Demand hit 1.16 Boz in 2024, down 3% overall but with industrial use smashing records at 680.5 Moz—up 4% and the fourth straight annual high.Silver's conductivity drives this: photovoltaics (PV) consumed 197.6 Moz in 2024, flat due to "thrifting" (reducing silver per panel by 10-15%), but global solar installations rose 25%, with projections doubling capacity by 2030 via policies like the U.S. Inflation Reduction Act. EVs added another layer—each requires 1-2 oz versus 0.5 oz in gas vehicles—with global production hitting 20 million units in 2025, potentially consuming 90 Moz. Electronics and AI data centers pushed total industrial demand to 59% of usage, up from 50% a decade ago. Investment demand rebounded to 300 Moz in 2024 (up 15%), with ETPs like SLV seeing 95 Moz inflows in H1 2025 alone, locking away 1.1 Boz since 2019 and tightening "mobile inventory." Jewelry fabrication grew 3% to 208.7 Moz, led by India's 13% export surge, though price sensitivity caps gains at $40+ levels. For 2025, total demand stabilizes at 1.20 Boz, with industrial flat at 680 Moz but investment up 7% to offset jewelry's 16% dip—now projected to exceed 700 Moz in industrial use for the first time, per updated Silver Institute data. From my analysis, green tech's 20% annual growth ensures a demand floor, while safe-haven flows—spurred by tariffs and debt worries—amplify volatility, with the gold-silver ratio at 85:1 signaling silver's undervaluation versus its 60:1 historical norm. September's rally to $41 reflects this, as industrial buyers lock in supply amid EV and solar booms, pushing year-to-date gains to 43%.

The Role of COMEX and Other Trading Hubs
COMEX, the dominant silver futures hub under CME Group, sets the global benchmark price but operates in a paper-dominated ecosystem. In 2025, daily trading volumes exceed 1 Boz—240 times annual mine production of 830 Moz—creating a 250:1 paper-to-physical ratio that distorts discovery. Physical deliveries, historically under 1% of contracts, exploded in 2025: Q1 alone saw record notices, with eligible stocks peaking at 504.72 Moz in May before easing to 518 Moz by September, amid tariff-driven inflows—now up 200% from 2024 as prices hit $41.
This surge signals institutional hedging, but delays in load-outs (up to weeks) highlight sourcing strains. Other hubs amplify this: LBMA vaults hold just 155 Moz (down 30-40% YTD), while Shanghai's futures exchange sees 100 Moz daily volume but limited exports due to China's 44% industrial demand spike. BRICS talks of a new precious metals exchange could bypass Western hubs, adding 5-10% volatility. In essence, these venues facilitate speculation—COMEX open interest hit 200,000 contracts (1 Boz equivalent) in H1 2025—but physical tightness, with EFP premiums at 5-10% over spot (now $41), underscores their disconnect from reality, especially as September deliveries strain amid the rally.
The Disconnect Between Paper and Physical Markets
Silver's paper-physical chasm is stark: futures trade 200-350 times physical supply, allowing banks to suppress prices via shorts (commercials held 40% of open interest short in Q2 2025). Yet, physical premiums hit 100% for 1-oz coins in the UK, with U.S. dealers reporting 20-50% over spot for bars—far exceeding COMEX's $41 average as of September 10. This gap, widened by 2025's 117 Moz deficit, echoes 2021's squeeze but persists: LBMA stocks fell 110 Moz YTD, while COMEX deliveries strained vaults. Retail and industrial buyers pay $45-50 for physical, decoupling from paper's volatility. I see this as bullish: as arbitrageurs demand delivery (up 18% margins at CME), paper prices must converge upward, with September's 9.15% monthly gain to $41 signaling the squeeze's acceleration—potentially testing $45-$50 by Q4.
Silver Equities: Leveraged Gains Amid Volatility
Silver equities have amplified the metal's rally, with the GDXJ ETF up 37% YTD in 2025 versus silver's 43%—now trading at a 0.9 price-to-NAV ratio, undervalued by 10% despite the September surge. Pan American Silver (PAAS) gained 20%, bolstered by its $2.1 Boz acquisition of MAG Silver, boosting production to 950,000 GEOs annually by 2030. Wheaton Precious Metals (WPM), a streamer avoiding mining risks, rose 25% on diversified streams yielding 15% margins at $41 silver. Juniors like First Majestic (AG) surged 40% post-$970 Moz Gatos deal, targeting 10-15 Moz output despite 10% cost hikes to $18/oz. Yet, risks loom: operational costs rose 10-15% from energy and labor, while Mexico's 25% tariffs threaten 5% production dips. SILJ ETF, tracking juniors, outperformed GDX by 15%, signaling exploration upside. In my assessment, equities offer 2-3x leverage to spot gains, with top picks like PAAS and WPM poised for 50% upside if silver hits $45-$50 as September forecasts suggest, though juniors' 20-30% volatility demands caution amid the current $41 peak.

 

Market Dynamics and Future Outlook

COMEX's $41 average masks physical premiums at 20-50%, with deficits projected at 1 Boz cumulative by 2028—now intensified by September's rally. Industrial demand (700 Moz forecast for 2025, up 3%) clashes with supply stagnation, while paper shorts (40% of OI) face squeeze risks as deliveries hit records. Equities, up 37% YTD, lag slightly behind spot's 43% but trade at discounts, offering entry points. Reflecting on September 2025, silver's surge to $41—outpacing gold's gains and Nifty's performance by over 50% in 12 months—highlights the deficit's real-world bite, with tariffs and green tech accelerating the bull. For 2025's remainder, I forecast silver averaging $42-$45 on COMEX, testing $50 by Q4 amid tariff escalations and EV/solar growth (200 Moz PV demand), aligning with optimistic projections like $46.19 end-September and $53.31 year-end. Risks include recessions curbing industrial use (10-15% drop) or silver-free tech (unlikely before 2030). Yet, BRICS exchanges and de-dollarization could add 10-20% volatility. Equities may double for low-cost producers if deficits persist.

 

My Take


Silver's 2025 narrative is one of imbalance: 148.9 Moz deficits in 2024 ballooning pressures, industrial demand at 680 Moz records (heading to 700 Moz), and paper-physical disconnects via COMEX's 250:1 leverage. Trading hubs like LBMA and Shanghai highlight global strains, while September's rally to $41—up 43% YTD—validates the bull, outrunning forecasts and underscoring undervaluation. Equities deliver 37% gains with upside potential. As I evaluate, silver's fundamentals—green tech, safe-haven flows, supply woes—point to $50+ by year-end, with equities as the leveraged play. Investors must prioritize physical or strong-balance-sheet names, monitoring tariffs and deliveries for the next leg up in this compelling bull.

Join our Newsletter!

Sign up to our free monthly newsletter to recieve the latest on our interviews and articles.

By subscribing you agree to receive our newest articles and interviews and agree with our Privacy Policy.
You may unsubscribe at any time.